Wednesday, June 13, 2012

DEAR SGT. AL: TAKING PHOTOGRAPHS OF OFF-LIMITS LANDMARKS


If you love this country and respect other people's property even if you pay taxes for it, then read and obey signs like this to leave it at that.  
DEAR SERGEANT AL: The other day I was in the subway waiting for the next train when I saw officers move in and give a photographer a ticket for taking pictures of all things. What kind of country are we becoming? Do the cops have the right to do that? – INQUIRING MINDS WANT A REASON TO SHOW

For anyone reading this who is over the age of 30, who would have thought we'd ever see the day we actually might get arrested for violating signs like this . . .
DEAR IMWARTS: Sorry to tell you, but most likely yes, the police do have the authority to do this, and for reason. Please remember that when we leave the streets of a major city and enter some kind of transit system downstairs or upstairs, we are no longer on public space or property. In many ways it’s like entering Macy’s or Wal-Mart, with the exception that state legislatures give such Macy’s or Wal-Mart special status and permission to establish rules that are enforceable by law. So if you break the law at the real Macy’s, they will have to call the local police like everyone else does to arrest and prosecute you. In the transit system, they can usually hire their own police, create a rule that is against the law to break, and then authorize their police or the local police to arrest for breaking that rule that is law. Depending on the state the transit system resides, and what the rules of the system are, the moment you pay money to ride that system and enter past the turnstiles, you are now on the property of a publicly run corporation usually called an authority. Under the rules of law that is not like the streets, and as such, such entities can set their own rules for the public good.
Here. This hopefully is as close a jet will get to the Golden Gate Bridge in my lifetime. Anyone else who needs to get any closer to the bridge to get a photograph needs to have their head examined.
The issue of public good now comes to the part of your question about the issue of taking photographs down in the subway, at a toll plaza, railroad tracks, airport terminal, or any significant landmark run by a government or an independent authority. Since September 11th, publically run agencies like the MTA, Amtrak, most port authorities, airport authorities, bridge, tunnel, highway or transportation authorities, etc. do not like to have their properties photographed without permission. If we can’t go to any NASA facility and start snapping away, we should expect the same if it’s about AMTRAK, even corporations like Conrail, Union Pacific, Boeing, thus even places like the Chesapeake Bay Authority, etc., as well. Some strictly enforce the rules governing this policy; others encourage their enforcement arm to use discretion. Of course NASA isn’t going to arrest you for taking a picture next to a space shuttle exhibit at Cape Canaveral. But I’d be weary if you wonder off alone on a NASA base taking pictures of an area off-limits that’s about something like an Air Force rocket on a NASA launch site. You’ll be okay on the Presidio side of the Golden Gate Bridge, but you’re looking for trouble if you’re caught on the Marin County side in a boat under the north anchorage of the bridge snapping away at support cables and columns. When you think about it that’s not cool unless you’re composing with family for a picture. 
Go to the images link in Google and type Golden Gate Bridge. There is a reason why all the pictures look the same, and few don't, because some parts of the bridge were not meant to be photographed. 

If there is an angle of the Golden Gate Bridge you need to look at, do us all a favor, and go on the internet to find it instead of trying to snap it yourself. This is a bridge. Terrorists are trying to knock it down. The people who take care of it don't want you taking pictures of certain angles. Get over it. 
And please don’t tell me this is America, we can take pictures wherever we want; that nowadays just sounds ASS-inine. When terrorists are arrested with photos and blueprints of infrastructure as they have on numerous occasions in the past, you can then understand why at times even the press must apply for a permit to take pictures on such properties. If you’re all wrapped up in the civil liberties thing, then I’ll jump onboard with you when it gets to the point when I can’t snap a picture anywhere on a typical street.

I’ll let you go this time with a stern warning IMWARTS: BEWARE. Unless the photo is a backdrop for a Griswald family snapshot at your favorite toll plaza or tunnel entrance which in any case I’d still look for signs to see if you can, I would be wary about taking any pictures of any publicly owned and run property unless it is a tourist attraction and without permission. You may not be outright arrested, but at the least you could be detained and have to answer lots of questions by their police, and have your photo equipment confiscated. We lost a bit of freedom that faithful day in 2001, but some say for a noble cause for the greater good of freedom and safety for all Americans. Drive, ride, and snap away CAREFULLY, RESPONSIBLY, and safely . . .
THERE IS A WAY OUT OF THIS INTERSECTION WITHOUT BREAKING THE LAW! Can you figure it out? HINT: Look at the signs and look for a direction that they are NOT indicating you can go. ANSWER: After you come to a full stop, and MAKE A U-TURN, you can proceed without the risk of being cited for a violation.  Good looking out for those of you who figured this out!


Suggested Reading:

What is a CARMAGEDDON and when will it happen? 
Am I allowed to walk on a highway?
Suggested Reading:
The definition of a “Concours” car and event
Suggested Reading:
Suggested Reading:
What is the new national terror alert warning?
Taking photographs at off-limits tourist landmarks .

0 comments:

Post a Comment

Sgt. Al here. I welcome your comments, ideas, and suggestions. You have questions about the police, and I'm interested in hearing what you have to say as a citizen. Thanks!

Pages